Services
People
News and Events
Other
Blogs

Challenging the Validity of a Will: What are the Legal Grounds?

 

Disputes over the validity of Wills can arise for a variety of reasons, particularly where a Will makes unexpected changes to the distribution of an estate or prompts concern about the circumstances in which it was prepared. However, testamentary freedom is a fundamental principle of English law, and dissatisfaction with the way a person chooses to distribute their estate is not sufficient of itself to invalidate a will.

There are 5 principal grounds upon which a Will may be challenged.

  1. A lack of testamentary capacity: under the test established in the old court case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870), the person making the Will must have understood the nature and effect of making a Will, the extent of their estate and the claims of those who might reasonably expect to benefit from it and not suffer from any ‘disorder of the mind’ that might impair or influence that understanding.
  2. A lack of knowledge and approval: the person making their Will must have understood and approved of the contents of their Will before signing. Someone who was blind, infirm or illiterate when signing, or suspicious circumstances such as a significant beneficiary being involved in preparing the Will, might lead to questions on this issue.
  3. Undue influence: a Will may be invalid where it is procured through coercion or pressure that substantially overpowered the free will of the person making the Will (meaning that the Will does not reflect their true wishes).
  4. Fraud or forgery: a challenge may arise where a Will has been forged or procured through fraudulent conduct.
  5. Failure to comply with formalities: section 9 of the Wills Act 1837 requires specific signing and witnessing formalities to be complied with for a Will to be valid.

In addition to challenges to the validity of a Will, eligible individuals may also pursue a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act 1975 where reasonable financial provision has not been made for them under the terms of a Will in certain specific circumstances. A claim under the Inheritance Act 1975 challenges the adequacy of any financial provision made under the Will, not the validity of the Will itself – but this type of claim is generally associated with other types of claims concerning Wills.

Ultimately, successful Will challenges depend on evidence rather than perceived unfairness, making early investigation and careful consideration of the available evidence essential.

If you would like more information about challenging the validity of a Will, please contact Hayley Banks at hcb@dawson-hart.co.uk, or call the Litigation Department on 01825 762281.

We are here for you when you need us.